The Impact of Treating Staphylococcus Aureus Infection and Colonization on the Clinical Severity of Atopic Dermatitis
Information source: Children's Memorial Hospital
Information obtained from ClinicalTrials.gov on October 19, 2009 Link to the current ClinicalTrials.gov record.
Condition(s) targeted: Atopic Dermatitis
Intervention: Sodium hypochlorite baths (Drug); Mupirocin ointment (Drug); Cephalexin (Drug); Water (Drug); Petrolatum Ointment (Drug)
Phase: Phase 4
Status: Recruiting
Sponsored by: Children's Memorial Hospital Official(s) and/or principal investigator(s): Jennifer Huang, MD, Principal Investigator, Affiliation: Childrens Memorial Hospital Amy Paller, MD, Study Director, Affiliation: Childrens Memorial Hospital
Overall contact: Brook Tlougan, MD, Phone: 773-327-9642, Email: b-tlougan@northwestern.edu
Summary
Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) infection is perceived not only as a common secondary
complication of atopic dermatitis (AD), but also as a culprit in the worsening of this
condition. In addition, the recent development of community acquired methicillin-resistant
S. aureus (CA-MRSA) has presented a new challenge to our management of AD, both in treatment
of acute infections and maintenance therapy. We would like to perform a randomized
investigator-blinded placebo-controlled study of children aged 6 months to 17 years with
moderate to severe atopic dermatitis with clinical signs of secondary bacterial infection to
study: 1) the prevalence of CA-MRSA in our patient population; 2) the relationship of
sensitivity of the S. aureus organism cultured from the infected lesion(s) to clinical
response to oral cephalexin therapy and severity of the AD; and 3) whether concurrent
treatment of S. aureus infection initially with nasal mupirocin ointment and sodium
hypochlorite (bleach) baths can result in long-term S. aureus eradication and clinical
stability.
Clinical Details
Official title: The Impact of Treating Staphylococcus Aureus Infection and Colonization on the Clinical Severity of Atopic Dermatitis
Study design: Treatment, Randomized, Double Blind (Subject, Investigator), Placebo Control, Parallel Assignment, Safety/Efficacy Study
Primary outcome: Clinical Severity of atopic dermatitis based upon Investigator's Global Assessment and EASI score
Secondary outcome: Safety outcomes, Pruritis scale
Detailed description:
Background Atopic dermatitis (AD) is a chronic condition of pruritus and eczematous lesions
that affects 15-20% of children. It commonly presents early in life and is associated with
other atopic diseases. Pathogenesis is multifactorial with genetic, immunologic, and
environmental components. Generally, decreased production of ceramides by keratinocytes in
both normal and affected skin causes disruption in skin barrier function, resulting in
increased permeability to environmental irritants and allergens, and transepidermal water
loss. There also is an immunologic derangement in the body's response to skin injury,
manifested by an increased Th2 response in the acute lesions. In addition, the change in
incidence of disease by time and climate suggests that environmental factors are important.
Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus) infection is not only a secondary complication of AD, but
also a culprit in exacerbations of AD. Of children with AD, 76-100% are colonized with S.
aureus, compared to 2-25% of healthy controls. In addition, S. aureus is the most common
cause of infected AD. The qualities of atopic skin may explain this high rate of
colonization and infection. 1) Patients with AD have poor expression of the natural
antimicrobial peptides (βdefensin2 and cathelicidin) during inflammation, likely increasing
the risk of cutaneous bacterial and viral infections. 2) The disrupted lipid layer of atopic
skin results in low sphingosine, which normally exerts a potent antimicrobial effect on S.
aureus. 3) S. aureus contains adhesins, which readily bind to laminin and fibronectin that
are exposed in patients with AD and skin injury. Consistently, the extent of S. aureus
colonization correlating with the severity of AD has been shown. This may be explained by 4)
S. aureus superantigens (Enterotoxins A & B, TSST-1) in the worsening of AD - via the
recruitment of T cells & APCs and the upregulation of cytokines without organism
elimination. The Th2 cell pathway is preferentially activated, releasing cytokines (IL-4,
IL-5, & IL-13), which induces further inflammation and glucocorticoid insensitivity.
First generation cephalosporins have been the mainstay of treatment for acute impetiginized
lesions, but the emergence of community acquired methicillin resistant S. aureus (CA-MRSA)
has presented a new challenge. Over the past decade, CA-MRSA rates as high as 74% have been
found in some regions of the U. S. MRSA has been detected at equal rates in AD and non-AD
patients. Although CA-MRSA has greater antimicrobial susceptibility than hospital acquired
MRSA, CA-MRSA is often resistant to typical first-line oral agents, including
cephalosporins. However, despite the contrary evidence, patients still clinically improve
when prescribed first generation cephalosporins. This observation requires confirmation. The
deleterious effects of S. aureus in activating AD and observation of improvement with
treatment have led researchers to consider eradication (or suppressed growth) of this
organism as an important component of treatment of AD. The anterior nares are the major
location for S. aureus colonization. Mupirocin ointment represents the mainstay of therapy
for eradicating S. aureus nasal carriage, with low resistance rates against CA-MRSA.
Recently, sodium hypochlorite (bleach) has become popular with many US pediatric
dermatologists. Bleach has long been used safely and efficaciously as a dental antiseptic.
This agent has also been shown in concentrations as low as 0. 005% to be effective against S.
aureus in wounds and ulcers. We have observed that use of sodium hypochlorite improves the
clinical appearance of AD, but no studies have been done to confirm this. Several studies
have attempted to show that eradication of S. aureus improves the severity of AD. Most
studies using topical mupirocin on affected skin lesions for up to two weeks have shown that
when S. aureus decolonization can be achieved, patients show clinical improvement. However,
skin is recolonized with S. aureus in subsequent months, resulting in worsening disease and
making long term treatment difficult. Many studies do not treat both nasal carriage and skin
colonization. Although intranasal mupirocin ointment may be sufficient to eliminate S.
aureus in healthy hosts, this organism's affinity for the specific features of atopic skin
argues for the concomitant use of direct topical antiseptics, such as dilute bleach, in this
particular patient population. In addition, most studies have neglected the possibility that
family members are likely to be colonized as well, contributing to recolonization.
Recolonization can also be affected by failure to continue to aggressively treat atopic skin
with appropriate topical therapy during and following eradication. Recently, a small study
was performed on adults with AD, using mupirocin, chlorhexidine wash, cephalexin, and
potassium permanganate showed significant clinical improvement in subjects. Finally, it is
of interest to determine if the exacerbation of atopic dermatitis with CA-MRSA infection is
greater than with methicillin-sensitive S. aureus (MSSA) infection. At least one virulence
factor, Panton-Valentine leukocidin, has been found in CA-MRSA that is not found in MSSA.
Understanding the relevance of the emergence of CA-MRSA to AD is pivotal in appropriately
treating secondary infections in patients with AD. Successful eradication of S. aureus
colonization from patients with moderate to severe AD may decrease the future number of
secondary infections and improve the overall severity of their disease.
Aims of study - #1: Assess the impact of CA-MRSA on secondary S. aureus infections in
children with atopic dermatitis. #2: To study whether eradication of S. aureus with nasal
mupirocin ointment and sodium hypochlorite baths in conjunction with appropriate skin care
regimen with emollients and topical steroids or calcineurin inhibitors can result in
long-term S. aureus eradication and clinical improvement. #3: To study the impact of
CA-MRSA on overall severity of AD. We will determine the predictive value of CA-MRSA versus
MSSA on the overall severity of AD based on the EASI score.
Study population Patients aged 6 months to 17 years with moderate to severe AD by
investigator global assessment (IGA) and clinical signs of bacterial skin infection
(weeping, crusting, pustular lesions) are eligible. Exclusion criteria include current or
recent use (within past eight weeks) of topical or oral antibiotics and allergy to the
cephalosporins or mupirocin. Up to 40 patients recruited will be enrolled.
Study Design This study will be a randomized investigator-blind placebo-controlled study.
Prior to intervention, qualitative bacterial cultures and sensitivities of the nares and the
most severely infected lesions will be obtained from all subjects. Severity of AD will be
scored by both the IGA and EASI scoring systems. Patients will continue daily emollient
application and clinician-determined topical anti-inflammatory therapy. All subjects will
receive cephalexin TID for two weeks. Twenty subjects and their household members will
receive intranasal mupirocin ointment BID for five days. The subjects will receive
cephalexin 50mg/kg/day (maximum of 2grams/day) divided TID for two weeks. These subjects
will continue the five day regimen of mupirocin once monthly for three months and receive
sodium hypochlorite baths twice weekly for three months. The other twenty subjects and their
household members will receive placebo intranasal ointment with the same schedule. At four
weeks and 12 weeks after initiation of therapy, qualitative bacterial cultures and
sensitivities of the nares and the most severely superinfected area will be obtained from
all subjects. One potential pitfall is the inability to perform quantitative bacterial
cultures, as our laboratory cannot do these and the send-out cost is prohibitive; it is
possible that the numbers of staphylococcal organisms will decrease, but be undetectable.
Blinding Mupirocin, sodium hypochlorite, and placebos will be stored in identical tubes and
bottles. Patients will be randomly assigned numbers 1-40 upon initial participation of
study. Based on their number, they will be assigned treatment A (treatment) or B (placebo).
The investigator will be blinded.
Assessment & Bacteriology At all visits, the %BSA affected by AD as estimated from 4 body
regions (head/neck, upper limbs, trunk, and lower limbs), and the Physician's Assessment of
Individual Signs grading the 6 signs of AD (erythema, edema/induration/papulation,
excoriation, oozing/weeping/crusting, scaling, and lichenification) will be determined. The
results will be used to calculate the EASI score, a validated composite score that ranges
from 0 (clear) to 72 (validated very severe). Additional assessments conducted at each visit
will be the IGA and the patient's assessment of itch using a visual analog scale (VAS).
Adverse events will be recorded at each visit. Swabs will be plated on blood agar and grown
for 48 hours at 37oC. S. aureus will be identified by testing for coagulase activity.
Antimicrobial susceptibility will be assessed using the agar disc diffusion method.
Sensitivity and resistance to several antimicrobials will be determined.
Treatment & Safety One-half cup of household bleach (sodium hypochlorite 6%) will be placed
in a full bathtub of water (40 gallons), diluting sodium hypochlorite to a concentration of
0. 005%. For most children, ¼ cup per half tub will be added. Patients will soak in sodium
hypochlorite baths twice a week for 3 months. Mupirocin ointment or placebo will be applied
to the nares for the subjects and families as detailed above. Cephalexin has proven to be
safe and efficacious for all ages. Potential adverse effects include abdominal pain,
diarrhea, transient elevation of liver enzymes, and allergic reactions. Inappropriate use of
cephalexin has led to resistant bacteriologic strains. Mupirocin ointment has been shown to
be safe and effective in neonates and children. Adverse reactions to mupirocin include
burning, stinging, pain or itching at the site of application. In less than 1% of patients,
nausea, contact dermatitis, and skin tenderness/swelling have been reported. While long-term
regimens may be associated with development of resistance, short courses of treatment with
mupirocin are associated with remarkably little bacterial resistance. Sodium hypochlorite in
low concentrations is a safe and widely used agent. Potential AEs include skin and eye
irritation. Our previous experience is that most children with AD tolerate bathwater with
dilute sodium hypochlorite without complication.
End points Primary outcome measure- change in EASI score from baseline to various timepoints
during the study. Secondary outcome measures- success of therapy based on IGA where success
equals "clear" or "almost clear" and failure equals all other IGA ratings, change in % BSA
affected; change in patient's assessment of itch using the VAS. Safety end points will
include the incidence of all AEs reported by patient or parent/guardian, or observed by the
investigator.
Eligibility
Minimum age: 6 Months.
Maximum age: 17 Years.
Gender(s): Both.
Criteria:
Inclusion Criteria:
- 6 months to 17 years of age
- Moderate to severe atopic dermatitis
Exclusion Criteria:
- Use of cephalexin or other antibiotic in last 6 weeks
- Allergy to cephalosporins
Locations and Contacts
Brook Tlougan, MD, Phone: 773-327-9642, Email: b-tlougan@northwestern.edu
Childrens Memorial Hospital, Chicago, Illinois 60614, United States; Recruiting Brook Tlougan, MD, Phone: 773-327-9642, Email: b-tlougan@northwestern.edu Jen Huang, MD, Email: jenhuang711@gmail.com
Additional Information
Starting date: September 2005
Ending date: December 2010
Last updated: June 5, 2008
|